Friday, January 18, 2013

Today in Labor History—January 18


January 18, 1920 – N.Y. ruled that teachers could be fired for Communist Party membership. (From the Daily Bleed)

January 18,1943 -- Mary Kenney O'Sullivan died on this date. She was the first American Federation of Labor (AFL) woman organizer and a cofounder of the National Women’s Trade Union League (WTUL). (From the Daily Bleed)
 

Dead Kennedys Rendition of “Take This Job and Shove It”

January 18, 1978 - Johnny Paycheck's "Take This Job and Shove It" hit the top of the Billboard music charts. (From Workday Minnesota)

Thursday, January 17, 2013

Teachers' Lack of Rights at Work AND Home


In a stunning defeat for free speech and privacy rights a two-person appellate panel has upheld the firing of Jennifer O’Brien (see North Jersey.com). O’Brien, you may recall, was the Paterson elementary school teacher who was suspended for posting to her Facebook page that she felt like a warden for future criminals (see Teachers, Check Your Freedoms at the Door). The panel ruled that her behavior was not protected by the First Amendment and that her right to make those comments was “outweighed by the district’s interest in the efficient operation of its schools.”

Of course O’Brien’s behavior was stupid (or at least incredibly naïve) in this charged, litigious and anti-teacher climate. Teachers really cannot assume they have the same right to privacy as other professionals. A teacher is still expected to be a paragon of virtue, on and off campus (see Teachers, Madonna and Whore). In the past, it was not uncommon for teachers to be fired for getting pregnant, married or for having a boyfriend. Yet, as crazy as it sounds, they still are (see here for a recent example of a teacher being fired for getting pregnant out of wedlock). Teachers’ behavior at home and in the community (e.g., public intoxication, provocative attire, participation in street protests and activism) and on the internet are all open to monitoring and judgment by students, parents and administrators.

Yet regardless of how callous, careless or insensitive one feels O’Brien was, it is hard to see how firing her was in the best interests of society or children. If she was a terrible teacher and these comments were just the latest example of her cruelty toward children, then yes, build a case and go through the proper dismissal procedures. If, on the other hand, it was simply a tactless expression of frustration or exasperation with discipline problems in the classroom by an otherwise decent teacher, then get her some support or professional development. After all, teachers constantly complain privately about discipline problems to each other and to friends and family. Some no doubt even use the same pejorative comments she used, but have the sense to keep such comments off the social networking websites. This does not make them bad teachers or a threat to children.

In contrast, firing O’Brien for cause (thus denying her unemployment benefits) is deliberately cruel and callous, and completely unnecessary. But since she is an adult who betrayed the public trust, an erstwhile defender of children’s innocence who slandered their purity, a whore in Madonna’s clothing, it is entirely reasonable—indeed, desirable—to throw her to the wolves.

Today in Labor History—January 17


Rabelais
January 17, 1536 – Francois Rabelais was absolved of apostasy by Pope Paul III and allowed to resume his medical practice. “Pantagruel” was published in 1532, which later became part of his larger work, “Gargantua and Pantagruel,” which satirized the nobility, the Church, the legal system, explorers, machismo and pretty much all that was sacred to the French ruling elite. Consequently, he was persecuted much of his life. Rabelais was said to have left a one sentence will: “I have nothing. I owe a great deal. The rest I leave to the poor.” (From the Daily Bleed and Wikipedia)

The Furred Law-Cats, From Gargantua and Pantagruel
THE FURRED Law-Cats are most terrible and dreadful monsters; they devour little children, and trample over marble stones. Pray tell me, noble topers, do they not deserve to have their snouts slit? The hair of their hides doesn’t lie outward, but inwards, and every mother’s son of them for his device wears a gaping pouch, but not all in the same manner; for some wear it tied to their neck scarfwise, others upon the breech, some on the side, and all for a cause, with reason and mystery. They have claws so very strong, long, and sharp that nothing can get from ’em what is once fast between their clutches. Sometimes they cover their heads with mortar-like caps, at other times with mortified caparisons.  Examine well the countenance of these stout props and pillars of this catch-coin law and iniquity; and pray observe, that if you live but six olympiads, and the age of two dogs more, you’ll see these Furred Law-cats lords of all Europe, and in peaceful possession of all the estates and domains belonging to it; unless, by divine providence, what’s got over the devil’s back is spent under his belly, or the goods which they unjustly get perish with their prodigal heirs. Take this from an honest beggar!  Among ’em reigns the sixth essence; by the means of which they gripe all, devour all, conskite all, burn all, draw all, hang all, quarter all, behead all, murder all, imprison all, waste all, and ruin all, without the least notice of right and wrong; for among them vice is called virtue; wickedness, piety; treason, loyalty; robbery, justice. Plunder is their motto, and when acted by them is approved by all men, except the heretics; and all this they do because they dare; their authority is sovereign and irrefragable. Should all their villany be once displayed in its true colours and exposed to the people, there never was, is, nor will be any spokesman could save ’em; nor any magistrate so powerful as to hinder their being burnt alive in their coney-burrows without mercy. Even their own furred kittlings, friends and relations would abominate ’em.

January 17, 1863 – The flush toilet was patented by Mr Thomas Crapper. (From the Daily Bleed)
Thomas Crapper Toilet at the Victor Horta Museum, Brussels (Image by Oxyman)
 January 17, 1873 – Four hundred federal troops were routed by Modoc Indians in the Tule Lake area of Northern California. (From the Daily Bleed)

January 17, 1898 – A two-day General Strike occurred in Ancône, Italy, following an increase in bread prices. Bread riots occurred in 50 other Italian towns, as well. The army occupied the city. Errico Malatesta and several other anarchists were charged with a "criminal conspiracy" against public security & property. During the trial 3,000 anarchists signed a declaration confessing to be guilty of the same crime. (From the Daily Bleed)
Lucy Parsons, 1920
 January 17, 1915 – Anarchist and organizer Lucy Parsons led hunger march in Chicago. (From the Daily Bleed)


Solidarity Forever (Weaver’s Version)

January 17, 1915 – Wobbly (IWW) Ralph Chapin published the famous labor song, "Solidarity Forever." (From Workday Minnesota and the IWW)
When the union's inspiration through worker's blood shall run,
There can be no power greater anywhere beneath the sun;
Yet what force on earth is weaker than the feeble strength of one,
For the union makes us strong.
[Chorus]
Is there aught we hold in common with the greedy parasite
Who would lash us into serfdom & would crush us with his might?
is there anything left to us but to organize & fight?
For the union makes us strong
[Chorus]
In our hands is placed a power greater than their hoarded gold,
Greater than the might of armies magnified a thousand fold;
We can bring to birth a new world from the ashes of the old,
For the union makes us strong.
[Chorus]: Solidarity forever, Solidarity forever, Solidarity forever,
For the union makes us strong
Words by Ralph Chaplin

January 17, 1961 – Patrice Lumumba, anti-colonial fighter and former premier of the newly independent Republic of the Congo (Zaire), was assassinated by the CIA. (From the Daily Bleed)

January 17, 1997 – Holt Labor Library (San Francisco), which specializes in labor and radical history, fired both of its workers, Ali Bruce and Kurt Biddle. Both were involved in a union organizing effort at New College and the Holt Labor Library. (From the Daily Bleed)

Wednesday, January 16, 2013

California Flunks Rhee’s Reform Ratings—Badge of Honor?

Image adapted from Flickr image by Calsidyrose

Michelle Rhee’s Students First advocacy group issued its ratings of state reform efforts last week. California was ranked 41st nationally, with an overall score of F, according to the Los Angeles Times.  According to Students First, California has been asleep at the wheel with respect to the “reforms,” failing to limit teacher tenure and require student test scores to evaluate teachers.

Richard Zeiger, Deputy Supt. at the California Department of Education called the F grade a "badge of honor."

While it may be refreshing to hear a high ranking education official disparage Rhee’s astroturf school privatization organization, the fact that California ranked so high on her list should still be an embarrassment. Consider that there are 9 other states that ranked lower than California which, according to the backward logic of Rhee, means there are 9 that have done a better job than California at resisting free market reforms. Furthermore, the only high mark California did receive was for being the birthplace of “parent trigger” laws, which are essentially a Trojan horse for corporate education profiteers and for-profit charter school operators to grab taxpayer dollars—hardly a mark of honor.

No states received an A from Rhee’s organization. The two top states were Louisiana and Florida, which each earned a B-. Louisiana has been one the quickest to give away its public schools to non-unionized private charter school operators, particularly in the wake of Hurricane Katrina. In New Orleans, over 70% of students now go to charter schools. Florida bases 50% of teacher evaluations on student test scores even though those scores are highly variable from year to year and completely unreliable for all but those at the extremes.

Even though Massachusetts has among the highest levels of student achievement, the state only received a D+ because it did not do enough to crush teachers unions and give away control of its schools to education profiteers. Montana received an F for strongly supporting local control of its schools.

Torlakson Calls for Less Testing—Modern School Calls for No Testing

(Image adapted from Flickr image by DefeatEd2K4)
California’s Superintendent of Schools, Tom Torlakson, has called for a reduction in the number of standardized tests that students must take. Under his new plan, second-graders would not be tested in math and English next year, and most high school tests would also be dropped, the Los Angeles Times report last week. However, because of federal requirements, students would still be tested in math and English in grades 3-8, and in science in grades 5, 8 and 10, and the California High School Exit Exam (CAHSEE) would also remain in place.

The Times gives the impression that there will be a significant reduction in high stakes standardized tests under the Torlakson plan. However, at the high school level, there really aren’t many universally administered high stakes exams beside the NCLB tests, and the state’s CST and high school exit exams. Thus, Torlakson is not really proposing a significant reduction in testing. Rather, because of the state’s implementation of the Common Core Standards, a new exam must be phased in over the next few years, making the current CST test redundant.

One Test is Too Many
All high stakes standardized tests are bad for children, teachers and schools, and they should all be abolished. They are expensive to administer and assess, and the preparation for the tests saps further resources for teachers’ professional development and the purchase of curriculum, supplies and textbooks. The tests are stressful for students, adding unnecessary anxiety to their already harried lives. The testing can take up to several weeks of class time, reducing the amount of time available for more student-centered activities that foster creativity, curiosity and critical thinking and this contributes to children’s alienation from and disdain for school.

Supporters argue that the tests are necessary for holding teachers and schools accountable. Torlakson himself called the current tests "a very powerful tool" for improving learning, according to the Times. However, there is no evidence that any high stakes standardized test accomplishes these goals, nor is there any reason to expect then to. The tests can only tell us how well a student compares to his peers in answering questions under pressure. They cannot tell us why one student does better than another under these conditions (e.g., smarter, better at working under pressure, more affluent and better access to resources at home, or better teachers).

Furthermore, even if the tests could answer these questions, a comparison between students should not be the goal. That a student is in the top quintile is far less relevant than knowing which benchmarks of achievement that student has met. While a university with limited space might be tempted to choose an applicant in the top 1% over one in the top 10% as a short cut in determining which is more likely to succeed or thrive at the school, the latter student could conceivably be the former’s equal (or better) at reading, writing, math, science or history, or more likely to succeed.

Benchmarks are also more useful than peer comparisons in determining whether students are graduating with the “necessary” skills. For example, if one goal of school is that all students graduate knowing how to calculate an average, it is irrelevant who can do it better or faster. Benchmark assessments tell us which students have mastered this skill. In contrast, the typical standardized test, which tells us which quintile a student falls into, will always have 20% of students in the lowest quintile, even if 100% of students mastered or failed a benchmark skill.

The Testing Will Continue Until Morale Improves
Children tend to start school with excitement and enthusiasm. It is a place to be with friends or make new ones. Learning, itself, is fun and exciting for children, or at least it can be when it is child-centered and the child is given ample freedom to explore and experiment and is provided encouragement and affection. Consider the difference between a teacher standing in the front of a group of students making them repeat after her, versus giving students the freedom to choose for themselves from a room full of toys, games and art and construction materials.

Tests are not inherently fun (though it is possible to trick younger children into thinking of them as a game). Tests require sitting still for extended periods of time. They are highly regimented, with fixed, inflexible structures and answers. Schools’ obsession with improving test scores compels many to replace free exploration and student-centered activities with rote memorization and test practice, activities that stifle curiosity and excitement. And many schools are starting this process at the K-2 grades, a time when free play is most critical.

LAUSD Superintendent John Deasy criticized Torlakson’s plan, saying they needed testing at the 2nd-grade level to identify at-risk students. He also worried that officials would have trouble identifying at-risk high schools. Yet teachers were able to identify their at-risk students before the advent of high stakes standardized tests. Likewise, districts have always been able to identify their struggling schools. What Deasy (and other “reformers”) really want is an “objective” measure of success and failure that they (not the teachers) control, that they can use to weaken teacher’s job security and working conditions and to steamroll through free market “reforms” that enrich their allies and benefactors. 

Today in Labor History—January 16


January 16, 1919 – Semaine Sanglante ("Bloody Week") ended on this date in Buenos Aires. The General Strike was crushed, with as many as 700 dead and 2000 wounded. The militant Argentinean anarchist movement is decimated by the repression which follows & trade union reformists gain control of the workers' movement. (From the Daily Bleed)

January 16, 1991 – U.S. invaded Kuwait and Iraq. By the end, an estimated 1,000,000 Iraqis died from bombings and the effects of the following five years of U.S.-led global economic embargo. (From the
Daily Bleed)

January 16, 1992 – The government of El Salvador and the FMLN rebels signed a peace accord, formally ending a 12-year-old civil war that killed 75,000, mostly civilians. (From the
Daily Bleed)

Tuesday, January 15, 2013

Friedrich Froebel—Farther of Kindergarten

Friedrich Froeble, (C.W. Bardeen, Publisher, c1897) {PD-US}}

Friedrich Froebel (April 21, 1782—June 21, 1852) was born in Thuringia, in a forest region known for its herbal medicines, soaps and salves. At the age of ten, he moved in with his uncle and, at the age of fifteen, he started an apprenticeship with a forester. In 1799 he left his apprenticeship to study math and botany in Jena. In 1805 he began his career as an educator at a secondary school in Frankfurt. It was there that he learned about the Swiss educator Johann Heinrich Pestalozzi, whose educational theories would have a significant influence on him. He was also influenced by Rousseau, Ficte, and the Taoists, Buddhists and ancient Greeks.

From 1813 to 1814 he participated in two campaigns against Napoleon. In 1816 he founded the German General Education Institute in Thuringia. In 1826 he published “The Education of Man,” (Die Menschenerziehung), his major literary work and also started the weekly periodical, “The Educating Families” (Die erziehenden Familien).

In the 1830s he began to produce playing materials for children and focused more on the education of preschool age children, creating a Play and Activity Institute in 1837 and coining the term Kindergarten in 1840. His educational play materials, known as Froebel Gifts (Froebelgaben), included building blocks and pattern activity books and are considered by many to be the world’s first educational toys.

Froebel’s most important contributions to education involved his recognition of the importance of activity and play in early childhood learning and his concept of Freiarbeit (free work). His first kindergarten involved singing, dancing, gardening and play with his Froebel Gifts. He also encouraged his students to be keen observers of nature, a quality no doubt influenced by his own scientific training (Froebel helped develop the new field of crystallography and was trained as a botanist and naturalist). Thus, kindergarten was not simply a poetic-sounding “garden” filled with children, but a literal garden for them to observe and interact with the natural world. His kindergarteners were also taught how to sow, harvest and prepare nutritious produce.

Froebel’s kindergarten ideal was suppressed by the Prussian government which found it “atheistic and demagogic” for its supposed denigration of religion and politics. Though he was a devout Christian (and the son of a Lutheran minister), he rejected the notion of original sin and promoted and practiced the coeducation of boys and girls, something that was very controversial in 19th century Germany. He also eschewed the use of the scriptures in his schools. He also promoted the idea that children should be able to grow and develop without the influence of arbitrary political and social priorities—something that would endear him to anarchists like Francisco Ferrer and others in the Modern School movement.

Froebel’s pedagogical theories influenced the later educational work of Maria Montessori and Rudolf Steiner, while his Froebel Gifts inspired the architectural aesthetic of Frank Lloyd Wright and Buckminster Fuller, as well as many of the Bauhaus artists. Because he saw mothers as the ideal first teachers, he actively encouraged women to teach in the first kindergartens, making kindergarten one of the first significant career opportunities for women at a time when women were often not allowed to work outside the home.

The first American kindergarten was founded at Watertown, WI, in 1856, by Froebel’s student Margarethe Schurz.

Pediatricians Call For More Recess

Recess (Image from Flickr by Sam Pullara)

The testing mania that has swept the nation for the past decade has been devastating for children in numerous ways. Testing is stressful for children. It takes away class time from more meaningful content and learning. It undermines creativity, curiosity and critical thinking. It also may be contributing to obesity and other health problems while also impairing cognitive development.

In order to increase time in the classroom—a common strategy for providing more test preparation and boosting test scores—schools across the country have eliminated PE and recess. According to the 4LAKids Blog, more than 40% of the nation’s school districts have reduced, eliminated or are considering eliminating recess. A 2012 survey of 1,800 elementary schools found that nearly one-third of schools did not offer any recess for their third-graders.

It is not just teachers that are complaining. The American Academy of Pediatrics (AAP) is also criticizing this trend, saying that recess gives children cognitive, social, emotional and physical benefits they cannot get while sitting at a school desk. The authors go further, stating the recess should not be denied to students for punitive or academic reasons. The Academy’s policy statement was based on several studies connecting recess to increased classroom attentiveness and productivity.

The Centers for Disease Control (CDC) recommends that schools require daily physical activity totaling 150 minutes a week for K-5 students and 225 minutes a week for 6th-12th-graders. However, even this seems woefully inadequate. 150 minutes per week averages out to only 30 minutes per day. Doctors recommend that adults get this much cardiovascular exercise per day just to maintain their physical health. However, according to the AAP, elementary school age children not only need 60 minutes of daily physical activity for good physical health, they also need it for their cognitive and emotional development.

Physical activity during the school day serves several functions. The most immediate effect is that it allows students a mental break from their academic content. Children have limited attention spans. Therefore, from a purely cost-benefit perspective it is inefficient to force students to sit still for long periods of time—the longer they sit still without a break, the lower their attention and concentration. However, recess also gives students the opportunity to hone their communication, problem solving and coping skills as they play games with peers, negotiate collaborative activities and resolve the inevitable conflicts that arise when having to share limited resources on the playground.

The AAP also said that PE should not be substituted for recess. This is because PE classes tend to be structured and have content standards and academic expectations, while recess tends to be unstructured, giving children more freedom to choose how to play and interact with peers. When it is treated as their own personal time, to use as they prefer, recess can be an empowering activity that contributes to their self-confidence and sense of responsibility, while promoting creativity and independence and countering the stultifying effects of traditional teacher-centered and rote curriculum.

Today in Labor History—January 15

Rosa Luxemburg

January 15, 1919 – Rosa Luxemburg and Karl Liebnecht, were murdered by German police. (From the Daily Bleed)

January 15, 1929 - Dr. Martin Luther King, Jr. was born on this date. King once said, "We look around every day and we see thousands and millions of people making inadequate wages. Not only do they work in our hospitals, they work in our hotels, they work in our laundries, they work in domestic service, they find themselves unemployed. You see, no labor is really menial unless you're not getting adequate wages." (FromWorkday Minnesota)
Karl Liebknecht
January 15, 1946 – 260,000 U.S. electrical workers struck against General Electric, Westinghouse and General Motors. (From the Daily Bleed)

January 15, 1978 -- The C.N.T., the Spanish anarchist trade union, held a demonstration drawing 10,000 protesters in Barcelona to oppose the Moncloa pact (which allowed only the communist C.C.O.O and the socialist U.G.T the right to represent workers. (From theDaily Bleed)

January 15, 1997 –A general strike was called by a coalition of South Korean labor unions. The unions claimed that 600,000 workers participated in the strike; the government claimed it was only 100,000. (From the Daily Bleed)

Monday, January 14, 2013

Johann Heinrich Pestalozzi—Father of Modern Education

Pestalozzi by Francesco Ramos (late 18th-early 19th century, Prado) {{PD-US}}

Johann Heinrich Pestalozzi (January 12, 1746—February 17, 1827) was a Swiss pedagogue and education reformer who believed that every individual had the ability to learn and the right to an education. He was also a strong believer in personal liberty and an advocate for the poor. Many of the principles of modern pedagogy have their roots in Pestalozzi’s philosophy and practice, including the ideas of student-centered, inquiry-based learning; a focus on the child’s interests and needs; cooperation and communication between the teacher and the parents; and active, rather than passive, learning.

As a boy, Pestalozzi traveled the countryside with his grandfather, who was a clergyman. On these travels, he witnessed the intense poverty suffered by the peasants and the consequences of putting children to work in the factories, as well as the ineffectiveness of the local Catechism schools. These experiences influenced the development of his future educational theories. Philosophically, Pestalozzi was most influenced by Rousseau, who was imprisoned by the Swiss as a subversive during Pestalozzi’s lifetime. Pestalozzi, himself, was imprisoned for a short time for his supposed role in the prison escape of a colleague, a charge that was no doubt influenced by his support for Rousseau and militant causes. 

Pestalozzi tried his hand in politics and farming before turning to education. He attempted to create a school for the poor in the 1770s, known as Neuhof, where peasants would be liberated from their poverty by learning to weave and by selling their products. He believed that he could prevent children’s alienation from the educational process by financing their own education through work. However, Neuhof ended in financial ruin for him and his family. The experience forced him to reconsider many of his assumptions, like the Romantic notion that work comes naturally to man—an idea that was dashed when he overheard his students reminiscing about the days when they were free to wander the countryside.
Pestalozzi with the orphans in Stans (1879, by Konrad Grob (1828 - 1904){{PD-US}}
 In 1798 the French army invaded the town of Stans, leaving many children without parents or homes and Pestalozzi was asked by the Swiss government to create on orphanage for the children. Here, with little support from the Swiss government, he became headmaster, teacher and nurse to the children.

Pestalozzi’s early pedagogy emphasized the combination of learning and industry. Initially, he believed his students could build things and sell them to help support the school. However, by the time of his involvement with the Stans orphanage, he believed crafts and work were much more valuable for their ability to develop students’ dexterity, attention, observation, memory and social interactions. Unfortunately, the French retook Stans in 1799 and commandeered the building in which his orphanage was housed.

Pestalozzi’s believed that rather than dealing with words, children should learn by doing and they should be free to pursue their own interests and draw their own conclusions. This was in marked contrast to the typical pedagogy of the day, in which the children learned entirely from books, lecture and rote repetition and memorization, often without understanding what they were repeating. Furthermore, most teachers in those days were not even trained as teachers. Pestalozzi eschewed the notion that teachers were there to give children answers. Thus, he felt it was imperative for the teacher to cultivate children’s power of observation and reasoning.

One of his early inventions was the use of cut out letters the students could use to construct words. He also etched letters into transparent horn-leaves, which the students could superimpose over their own letters to see if they wrote them correctly. Pestalozzi had so much success with his innovations that a school inspector in Burgdorf wrote that his children learned as much in half a year as the other teachers’ students were learning in three years.

By 1804, Pestalozzi’s fame had spread to and people began to study and emulate his methods in Germany, France, Italy, England, Russia and the U.S. He even received a job offer from the Czar of Russia. He refused, and later told the Czar he should abolish serfdom and open schools for the peasants.

Pestalozzi’s pedagogy was also based on respect for his students’ individual personalities and their personal dignity, as well as a deep sense in social justice and personal liberty. He encouraged classroom visits and participation by parents and believed strongly in regular communication with them about their children’s progress. Yet he opposed the concept of report cards, saying “No child is to compare himself with others.” He accepted children from all backgrounds, including those with emotional problems, and even opened a school for hearing impaired children. These ideas became the basis for the pedagogies of Friedrich Froebel (inventor of kindergarten and Froebel Gifts), Francisco Ferrer (founder of the first Modern Schools) and many of the libertarian educators that followed.